New Competitors Help Validate Your Market


Competition can be scary. There’s no doubt about it. Many of us have probably had a holy crap moment upon discovering new competition. And just imagine if that competition is a behemoth … like Google.

James Siminoff isn’t worried about Google entering into his competitive landscape. In fact, he’s openly thanking Google for doing so. James recounts the story of VCs asking him the classic question, “But what happens if Google enters your space?” Here’s his response:

My answers has always remained the same, “It is not what you do IF Google enters your market it is what you do WHEN they do.” If you can not answer that, then you should not be putting time and money into a business that you are obviously incapable of making successful.

In fact, if you’re ever pitching VCs you should be prepared for that question on competition, especially with respect to competition from “the big boys.”

Truthfully, Google would worry me. So kudos to James for taking an aggressive stand against them, and doing so in a public manner. He does have a point, Google’s forays into businesses outside search and advertising haven’t been as hugely successful. Google Talk certainly didn’t kill Skype. And Jaiku doesn’t even register vs. Twitter.

Every industry has its behemoths. Some of those big boys are more competent than others, but oftentimes they’re not the most innovative or fast-moving. So the lean, mean startup holds a certain advantage in that department.

As well, entrants into your space help validate that market, especially if you’re ahead of the game trying to change things. When a big, sleeping giant suddenly wakes up and says, “We have to get into that space!” it serves as validation and can be leveraged to your advantage. Industries and markets always have multiple players, and even if a big giant takes a leadership role, there are opportunities for smaller players – to grow sizable businesses, get acquired (by the big guy’s competition), etc.

Market validation helps a market grow. It drives more customers – who are acting as followers vs. leaders – to make buying decisions. It creates buzz. It awakens the interest of investors. You don’t want to be in a market alone (at least until you’ve crushed all the competition and are steps away from world domination), because it’s simply put, not a real market with any sizable opportunity.

The economic downturn has created a ton of opportunity in many old-school industries. Those industries might have been slow moving in the past, but have no choice but to re-invent themselves in a huge way, or die off almost completely. It’s times like these when small, innovative companies suddenly see their ideas, goals and businesses take hold – enough to wake up everyone else who jumps onto the “innovation train” too slowly and too late. So take advantage of the tumultuous times; make sure you stay ahead of the “big players” that jump into direct competition with you. And be ready to take advantage of competition by leveraging the validation they create in the market.

If you enjoyed this post, please share it!



April 3, 2009 Posted in Customer Development by

  • http://exvisu.com/ Michael

    Over the years I’ve come across this issue many times and when I was younger I thought it was ideal to have a true greenfield opportunity. With time though I heard again and again that many investors and analysts won’t take seriously a company that a) has no competitors or worse b) thinks it has no competitors.

    At the end of the day, success is based on great execution, not on having an idea that no one else has had yet.

  • http://exvisu.com/ Michael

    Over the years I’ve come across this issue many times and when I was younger I thought it was ideal to have a true greenfield opportunity. With time though I heard again and again that many investors and analysts won’t take seriously a company that a) has no competitors or worse b) thinks it has no competitors.

    At the end of the day, success is based on great execution, not on having an idea that no one else has had yet.

  • http://www.econ-jobs.com joe

    its quite reassuring that google doesnt succeed in all of its projects, i was beginning to think that the economy and our leaders would become one and the same.. Google, Inc. although the economics is sometimes scary, when google video lost to youtube it just bought youtube

  • http://www.econ-jobs.com joe

    its quite reassuring that google doesnt succeed in all of its projects, i was beginning to think that the economy and our leaders would become one and the same.. Google, Inc. although the economics is sometimes scary, when google video lost to youtube it just bought youtube

  • http://www.trade4all.com Forex Trading

    Great site keep, I really like the layout and will be giving you a link back from my site.

  • http://blog.timandren.com Tim Andren

    I really enjoyed reading this. It's a fresh perspective on approaching positioning too. It's as if business owners can be assured they are swimming in the right pool but also need to think about how to position their income stream or marketing in that pool.

  • http://blog.timandren.com Tim Andren

    I really enjoyed reading this. It's a fresh perspective on approaching positioning too. It's as if business owners can be assured they are swimming in the right pool but also need to think about how to position their income stream or marketing in that pool.

  • David Smith

    This is a good post!…Enjoyed going through the whole lines and YES…. that is a strong stand. And right said!…. you have to make a [url=http://www.filter-outlet.com/]business successful[/url] on your own when you invest money into it.

  • http://www.detectives.com Detectives

    interesting!
    now i know how to get into the competitive market

  • http://forextrading-tutorial.com Jack

    Ah well, it is the nature of the beast.. If you are not evolving then your are going to go stale. Same goes for Google. To their credit they have been very innovative, but who is to say they will stay that way?

  • http://www.attorneysync.com/topic/illinois-lawyers/chicago-personal-injury-lawyer Chicago Personal Injury Lawyer

    Great article. While we're fortunate enough not to have to chanllenge the googliath yet, there are certainly some large players in the Chicago personal injury lawyer market. As recognized above, being smaller does have its advantages.

    At the risk of redundancy and stating the obvious, survival really does come down to positioning.

    Often times, the very large try to be everything to everybody. To compete, figure out what you do best, and do it.

  • http://www.attorneysync.com/topic/illinois-lawyers/chicago-personal-injury-lawyer Chicago Personal Injury Lawyer

    Great article. While we're fortunate enough not to have to chanllenge the googliath yet, there are certainly some large players in the Chicago personal injury lawyer market. As recognized above, being smaller does have its advantages.

    At the risk of redundancy and stating the obvious, survival really does come down to positioning.

    Often times, the very large try to be everything to everybody. To compete, figure out what you do best, and do it.

  • http://www.chiropracticlifeblog.com Jeremy McMinn

    “New Competitors Help Validate Your Market”. I really liked that title and helps me out as lately I have been having a struggle coming to terms mentally dealing with competitors. Thanks for the post.

  • http://www.chiropracticlifeblog.com Jeremy McMinn

    “New Competitors Help Validate Your Market”. I really liked that title and helps me out as lately I have been having a struggle coming to terms mentally dealing with competitors. Thanks for the post.

  • http://www.alltverladies.com Single Russian Lady

    Good article. Competitors are inevitable. Whatever the company is there is someone who tries to cramp it. Google is a big company, of course many want to step into her shoes. you shoud decide what you do best of all and just do it. that is all.

  • http://www.herbalreleaf.com/ Herbal Care

    Without competitors is not a game. It is ugly to be unique in my opinion and also really hard. Competitors make you strive for perfection.

  • http://www.vaginoplastyprocedure.com/ vaginoplasty

    competitors is the real deal! I STRONGLY recommend competitors to EVERYONE interested in running a successful online business! I don’t know how I ever worked without it.

  • http://www.accuplace.com/ print & apply

    I really impressed when reading this, especially James Siminoff's comment about “when Google enters in market” question. It shows that we have to be always positive thinking person to be in business.

  • http://www.worldwidemakemoneyonline.com/ Alan

    Great articles. I must say competition is a good element for improving what your are doing. But when a competition is out of control then action must be taken to prevent a huge loses.

  • gokhanht
  • http://www.tennesseewrongfuldeathlawyer.net/ wrongful_death_lawyer

    I'm so love this blog, already bookmarked it! Thanks.

  • http://www.tennesseewrongfuldeathlawyer.net/ wrongful_death_lawyer

    I'm so love this blog, already bookmarked it! Thanks.

About Ben Yoskovitz
I recently joined GoInstant as VP Product. GoInstant changes how we use the web, making it shareable like never before.

I'm also a Founding Partner at Year One Labs, an early stage accelerator in Montreal. Previously I founded Standout Jobs (and sold it). I'm a hands-on startup guy, helping companies grow successfully from the idea forward. You can reach me at byosko at gmail dot com.

Follow Ben on TwitterFollow this blog via email
Startup Tools
Find Stuff
Please Check Out:
NextMontreal.com I Spy Montreal
Disclaimer
The opinions and commentary on this site are mine and mine alone. They do not necessarily reflect the opinions or positions of my employer, GoInstant.